Best Used Auto Parts Stores in Sag Harbor - Reviews, Perks & Phones
New York

Discover excellence in used auto parts stores in Sag Harbor, NY with our selection of the 10 best, backed by real experiences of those who have already trusted their services.

  • 1
    Aaron Auto Supply Corp.

    Aaron Auto Supply Corp.

    136 Peconic Ave, Medford, NY 11763

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    38.2 miles  5/5 - 10 reviews 


          Valentia D. Google Review

    "06:22/2023 Aaron’s BodyShop saved my LIFE !!! I walked in — frustrated because someone hit my door and ran, I was Quoted thousands of dollars to get a new door BUT to my best if Lucks- they..."


  • 💵 Want to sell your car in Sag Harbor, NY?

    1. Get an instant offer by calling 1-833-693-5944 or filling out our online form.
    2. Maximize your car's value by selling its parts individually through a classified ad.
    3. Contact junkyards directly from the list below.
    OR Call us Free: 1-833-693-5944
  • 2
    Kleemann's Auto Parts

    Kleemann's Auto Parts

    49 Long Society Rd, Preston, CT 06365

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    39.9 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Existing I. Google Review

    "It's almost been a year since their closure due to death in the family. I've checked the door 5 times and they are no longer open at all. Not any hours of any day. Darn shame. I really wanted to..."


  • 3
    Chick's Used Auto Parts

    Chick's Used Auto Parts

    403 N Cherry St Ext, Wallingford, CT 06492

    Used Auto Parts / Part Installation Service

    43 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Robert P. Google Review

    "Willie and Tony are some of the friendliest guys you're ever going to meet excellent mechanics and you're always going to leave satisfied and the prices are fair."


  • 4
    North End Auto Parts Inc

    North End Auto Parts Inc

    963 N Colony Rd, Meriden, CT 06450

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    47 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Robert C. Google Review

    "Eric and Tim are great prices are great and the parts are quality I've been dealing with them for years and never had a problem with a part."


  • 5
    East Coast Auto Salvage Incorporated

    East Coast Auto Salvage Incorporated

    733 Killingworth Rd, Higganum, CT 06441

    Used Auto & Truck Parts / Self Service

    34.5 miles  4.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Jenny M. Google Review

    "I love this place. The gentleman that answered the phone has such a pleasant personality with a charming accent. I called 13 other places and he had the part I needed...Made me a happy girl. He..."


  • 6
    Crushtheogre's used Jeep parts

    Crushtheogre's used Jeep parts

    8 Matthews Dr, East Haddam, CT 06423

    Used Auto Parts

    33.6 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Mike C. Google Review

    "Got 4 wheels and tires. Great guy. Told me what he had, gave me a good price, and helped me load them. Can't ask for better. Been running them for a few months."


  • 7
    Salvage Zone inc

    Salvage Zone inc

    1485 Montauk Hwy, Bellport, NY 11713

    Used Auto & Truck Parts / Shipping Available

    37.9 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Kyriakos L. Google Review

    "Salvage Zone has been my go to spot for over 10 years. As a construction company we constantly need to add to our fleet. Steve and his team have always been Super Pros about fulfilling our needs..."


  • 8
    Petrillo's Used Auto Parts

    Petrillo's Used Auto Parts

    150 Middletown Ave, New Haven, CT 06513

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    38.7 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Tanner C. Google Review

    "While working at a small dealership in upstate New York, i have dealt with dozens of used part yards. Called petrillos for the first time as they are not local. Isaac is the best sales rep i..."


  • 9
    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    899 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

    Used Auto Parts / Part Installation Service

    4.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Sara L. Google Review

    "The best place to go if you have any questions about products. The staff is absolutely awesome- every time I’ve been, whoever was working was very helpful. They even went so far as to help..."


  • 10
    Advance Auto Parts

    Advance Auto Parts

    1071 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901

    Used Auto Parts / Part Installation Service

    3.3/5 - 3 reviews 


          Patrick D. Google Review

    "was on line at the riverhead store during a very busy time and watched how they handled the counter. nothing is ever perfect but this was damm close. Dave helped me out when it was my turn and I..."


🤓 Did you know... The businesses shown here have been selected and ordered based on both our quality criteria and reviews shared by real people. Learn more about our selection and ranking criteria.