Best Used Auto Parts Stores in Payne County - Reviews, Perks & Phones
Oklahoma

Enter the world of used auto parts stores in Payne County, OK with our exclusive compilation of the 10 best, evaluated by people like you. We simplify your choice by providing you with authentic reviews and real experiences.

πŸ’‘ Tip: Filter by City to view the best used auto parts stores in your area.

  • 1
    Cars and Parts by Tim Inc.

    Cars and Parts by Tim Inc.

    4514 S Division St, Guthrie, OK 73044

    Used Auto Parts

    38.2 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 8 AM


          Paul O. Google Review

    "I got there took them about 10 minutes to get my part out to me. They loaded it for me as well, most other places i have to load the transmission. And prices are pretty good too. Staff was real..."


  • πŸ’΅ Want to sell your car in Payne County, OK?

    1. Get an instant offer by calling 1-833-693-5944 or filling out our online form.
    2. Maximize your car's value by selling its parts individually through a classified ad.
    3. Contact junkyards directly from the list below.
    OR Call us Free: 1-833-693-5944
  • 2
    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    5411 W 6th Ave, Stillwater, OK 74074

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    4.3/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          James O. Google Review

    "6/23/23 11A.M. β€” I don’t know how this guy ended up being the only person working today (at least up front) but talk about service! Dude was handling 2 phone calls and still managed to offer..."


  • 3
    Grigsby auto salvage,repair

    Grigsby auto salvage,repair

    312 Broad St, Sand Springs, OK 74063

    Used Auto Parts / Part Installation Service

    37.4 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 9 AM


          James P. Google Review

    "I've known Gary since 1976 & can honestly say that the Grigsby family still operate under the "old school" standards, which means that what he tells you is what he'll do. Along with..."


  • 4
    A-1 Auto Parts & Salvage

    A-1 Auto Parts & Salvage

    13521 E Apache St, Tulsa, OK 74116

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    54.4 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 8 AM


          Penny S. Google Review

    "They pull the parts for you but still give great prices! Their computer system allows you to call and check if they have your part available. Lastly, they are fast and efficient. I went prepared..."


  • 5
    Logan County Auto Salvage

    Logan County Auto Salvage

    Brookside St, Guthrie, OK 73044

    Used Auto Parts

    37.1 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 9 AM


          Camaryn B. Google Review

    "Harold was kind, easy to talk to and very helpful! Definitely will be going back for anything else I need help with!."


  • 6
    Subaru Genuine Used Auto Parts

    Subaru Genuine Used Auto Parts

    401 SE 59th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73129

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service / Shipping Available

    57.1 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Dani H. Google Review

    "Always have had a great experience dealing with this guys. Willing to answer any questions and always shipping parts much quicker than expected. Super fair pricing and love supporting small..."


  • 7
    LKQ Apex Tulsa

    LKQ Apex Tulsa

    7600 Charles Page Blvd, Tulsa, OK 74127

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    40 miles  3.3/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 8 AM


          Gentry B. Google Review

    "They had what I needed at a reasonable price. They showed me two parts with the same model/serial numbers but gave me the more worn looking one. Or I would have given them five stars."


  • 8
    66 Auto Salvage

    66 Auto Salvage

    6471 OK-66, Tulsa, OK 74131

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    39.7 miles  4.7/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 8 AM


          Michael Y. Google Review

    "Absolutely great part and solid service! Not only that they sold me a fantastic Mercedes engine with honestly advertised miles, but also the way it was pulled and crated is truly praiseworthy. It..."


  • 9
    Midwest Pull 'N Save

    Midwest Pull 'N Save

    3637 N Lewis Ave, Tulsa, OK 74110

    Auto Parts Market / Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    47.7 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews  opens at 9 AM


          Danny G. Google Review

    "Great place cheep prices. I recommend Midwest for most of your auto part needs also bring some drinks with you it's hot back there."


  • 10
    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    1143 E Main St, Cushing, OK 74023

    Used Auto Parts

    open now

πŸ€“ Did you know... The businesses shown here have been selected and ordered based on both our quality criteria and reviews shared by real people. Learn more about our selection and ranking criteria.