Best Used Auto Parts Stores in Honeoye Falls - Reviews, Perks & Phones
New York

Enter the world of used auto parts stores in Honeoye Falls, NY with our exclusive compilation of the 10 best, evaluated by people like you. We simplify your choice by providing you with authentic reviews and real experiences.

  • 1
    Dumbleton Used Auto Parts Inc.

    Dumbleton Used Auto Parts Inc.

    7223 Morrow Rd, Pavilion, NY 14525

    Used Auto Parts / Shipping Available

    3.3/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Arianna C. Google Review

    "I ordered an engine from this company through Part Cycle, and it arrived fairly quickly. I had a private licensed mechanic inspect the engine before putting it into my car, and although he did..."


  • 💵 Want to sell your car in Honeoye Falls, NY?

    1. Get an instant offer by calling 1-833-693-5944 or filling out our online form.
    2. Maximize your car's value by selling its parts individually through a classified ad.
    3. Contact junkyards directly from the list below.
    OR Call us Free: 1-833-693-5944
  • 2
    British Auto

    British Auto

    600 Walworth Penfield Rd, Macedon, NY 14502

    Used Auto & Classic Car Parts / Self Service

    4.3/5 - 6 reviews 


          Chip S. Google Review

    "Just picked up the missing part for a brake job on my MGB. The owner is the kind of guy that appreciates the cars and the community of people that own them. Very reasonable as well. Use your..."


  • 3
    Myles Auto Parts

    Myles Auto Parts

    238 Center St, Canandaigua, NY 14424

    Used Auto Parts

    5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Elizabeth V. Google Review

    "I won't go anywhere else for parts. Every time I need something for my vehicle they have it in stock or in store within 24 hours with the best price anywhere in the Ontario and Monroe..."


  • 4
    P J's Auto Parts

    P J's Auto Parts

    2708 Caledonia-Leroy Rd, Caledonia, NY 14423

    Used Auto Parts / Shipping Available

    3.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Rodney M. Google Review

    "Called looking for a somewhat hard to find part, talked to Bill, he was very helpful in finding the part I was asking for and completed the transaction via phone. Item arrived a few days later..."


  • 5
    Long Pond Auto Parts

    Long Pond Auto Parts

    1620 Long Pond Rd, Rochester, NY 14626

    Used Auto Parts / Part Installation Service

    5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Scott M. Google Review

    "Very knowledgeable and helpful. I always get the right parts, and they seem to be better quality than big box stores. Great inventory. I drive from the city to shop here, passing dozens of..."


  • 6
    Northside Salvage Yard - Used Auto Parts

    Northside Salvage Yard - Used Auto Parts

    860 Linden Ave, Rochester, NY 14625

    Used Auto Parts Store

    5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Petar M. Google Review

    "Couldn't have asked for better price for great parts, second time doing business, really happy."


  • 7
    Wilbert's Premium Auto Parts of Ontario

    Wilbert's Premium Auto Parts of Ontario

    6333 Lakeside Rd, Ontario, NY 14519

    Used Auto Parts Store / Used Auto Parts

    5/5 - 3 reviews 


          Onyx W. Google Review

    "I had a wonderful experience at this location I dealt with the one Neil, his expertise was unmatched, his vision, and his description of what my problem was I mean the guy is late amazing..."


  • 8
    NAPA Auto Parts - Ontario Auto Parts

    NAPA Auto Parts - Ontario Auto Parts

    1250 NY 104 Suite 90, Ontario, NY 14519

    Used Auto Parts

    5/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Caprice C. Google Review

    "Being in the automotive business for 25 yrs, I ran into a situation that no matter what parts store I called or visited they could not help. I stopped by the Macedon Napa for a final try, and..."


  • 9
    F A Products

    F A Products

    265 David Pkwy, Ontario, NY 14519

    Auto Parts Market

    3.7/5 - 3 reviews 


          Bernard K. Google Review

    "Very knowledgeable and willing to offer advice. Was well worth the drive to do business with them."


  • 10
    Advance Auto Parts

    Advance Auto Parts

    1971 NY 104, Ontario, NY 14519

    Used Auto Parts

    3.3/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Tony T. Google Review

    "Went to go someplace at 8:45 last night and my battery was cooked. Tried to jump it, she was toast. I had a full day ahead, bringing my oldest to summer camp, DRs appointment, needed to get to..."


🤓 Did you know... The businesses shown here have been selected and ordered based on both our quality criteria and reviews shared by real people. Learn more about our selection and ranking criteria.

FAQs on used auto parts stores in Honeoye Falls

Can I pay with a credit card?

+
−

Many salvage yards and used auto parts stores accept credit cards as a payment method. In case of some self-service junkyards, may accept credit cards for entrance fees or additional services, but many primarily deal in cash transactions. The nature of self-service yards, where customers pull their own parts, often involves a simpler and more straightforward payment process, and cash is commonly preferred.

What types of car parts can I find?

+
−

They typically have a wide range of parts, including engines, transmissions, body panels, interior components, and more.

Can I return a part if it doesn't fit or work?

+
−

In case of junkyards, some have strict no-return policies, especially for self-service yards where customers pull their own parts. On the other hand, many salvage yards and used auto parts stores may offer more lenient return policies. However, it's essential to inquire about and understand the specific terms and conditions before making a purchase.

How realiable are the parts they sell?

+
−

These come from pre-owned automotive components sourced from vehicles that have been retired, damaged, or otherwise no longer in use. Quality and reliability can vary depending on the source and the inspection processes carried out by the salvage yard, junkyard, or seller.

  • Junkyard parts come from vehicles found in a junkyard, a place where decommissioned, wrecked, or older vehicles are stored, and parts are available for salvage. These are cheaper but less carefully inspected or tested compared to other options.
  • Salvage parts are components salvaged from vehicles that have been deemed a total loss by insurance companies due to accidents, damage, or other reasons. These are usually inspected and, if deemed usable, are removed and made available for resale. Salvage yards may have stricter guidelines for assessing the condition of these parts compared to typical junkyards.

While can be a cost-effective solution, especially for older or less common vehicles, it's essential to approach the purchase with caution.

Can I negotiate prices of used parts?

+
−

Is possible at some junkyards, particularly if you're purchasing multiple parts.

Do they sell used tires and wheels?

+
−

Yes, you can often find used tires and wheels in good condition.

How can I ensure a part will fit my vehicle?

+
−

Bring your vehicle's make, model, year, and VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) to verify compatibility.

Articles that may be of interest