Top 10 Used Auto Parts Stores in Wisconsin based on customer reviews

Discover excellence in used auto parts stores in Wisconsin with our selection of the 10 best, backed by real experiences of those who have already trusted their services.

💡 Tip: Filter by City to view the best used auto parts stores in your area.

  • 1
    1. AJ Auto Salvage Ltd

    300 Storck St, Slinger, WI 53086

    5/5 - 1 reviews 

    truck parts supplier used auto, truck & classic car parts towing service 

    The truck parts supplier offers a broad selection of high-quality parts for various makes and models. Whether you need a new radio, engine components, or suspension parts, they have everything you need to keep your truck running smoothly and safely. With their convenient location and expert assistance, you can trust that you'll find the right part for your vehicle without any hassle.


          John T. SalvageParts Review

    No email address?

    "My plan is to drive up from Waukesha and buy a radio #N03020 for my 04 Trail Blazer. I do not want to be stopped and ticketed for being out on the road. Do you get down this way? Mike at B&M set..."more

  • 💵 Want to sell your car in Wisconsin?

    1. Get an instant offer by calling 1-833-693-5944 or filling out our online form.
    2. Maximize your car's value by selling its parts individually through a classified ad.
    3. Contact junkyards directly from the list below.
    OR Call us Free: 1-833-693-5944
  • 2
    2. Van's Auto Salvage

    N3147 Center Rd, Waupun, WI 53963

    5/5 - 1 reviews 

    used auto & classic car parts 

    With a vast inventory of over 3000 cars ranging from the late 40's to early 80's, this family-owned auto parts store is a treasure trove for those in search of used vehicle parts. Specializing in mostly domestic cars and trucks, they are the go-to spot for economic repairable vehicles and spare parts.


          Mark R. SalvageParts Review

    1991 ford tempo

    "Called and talked to robert the owners son and had a great experience talking about the used repairable vehicles they have for sale. would highly recommend to others looking for a cheap vehicle..."more

  • 3
    3. Auto Parts and Recycling

    W4726 Co Rd A, Fredonia, WI 53021

    5/5 - 6 reviews 

    used auto & truck parts self service shipping available 

    The perfect way to economize large amounts of money on used parts for your car is to contact this junkyard in the Fredonia neighborhood, this is an attractive option. Other customers have left 6 thoughts about this business.


          Jerry H. Google Review

    "I had no idea there were still old-school salvage yards where you can go pick your own parts. You're basically shown a map on the wall and all the cars are organized by make. Just come back to..."more

  • 4
    4. Bradley Auto, Inc.

    2026 CR A, West Bend, WI 53090

    5/5 - 4 reviews 

    used auto parts self service 

    Looking to find affordable used auto parts for your vehicle? You're in the right place! This self-serve used auto parts store offers a wide selection of car parts at great prices. Our friendly staff is always ready to help and provide directions when needed. With a variety of vehicles to pull parts from, you're sure to find what you need in our yard.


          Adrian J. Google Review

    "The employees were very nice and friendly, gave me directions when I asked, helped me when I had questions. I definitely enjoyed my experience there and will definitely go back."more

  • 5
    5. Harper Salvage

    3066 State Hwy 13, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965

    3.7/5 - 3 reviews 

    used auto parts self service shipping available 

    With a self-serve option and a wide selection of used parts, this salvage yard is the go-to place for car enthusiasts and DIYers. Whether you're looking for a specific part or just browsing for project ideas, their extensive collection of vehicles makes it easy to find what you need. The helpful staff and reasonable prices ensure a positive experience for all customers.


          Daniel H. Google Review

    "Very busy yard, but they made time to bring up a car from there yard for me to pull parts off that I needed. Excellent service and reasonable prices. Will be back for more parts for my projects."more

  • 6
    6. Wally's U Pull It

    4266 WI-21, Oshkosh, WI 54904

    4.8/5 - 4 reviews 

    used auto & truck parts self service 

    Find the parts you need at this self-serve salvage yard. With a wide selection of used parts available from vehicles old to new, this junkyard is organized by manufacturer for easy browsing. Suited for those who like to pick their own parts at reasonable prices, it's a key location for DIY car repairs.


          Joe S. Google Review

    "One of my favorite pick your own part junk yards. They always have a fresh selection of a wide range of vehicles, old to new. Yard is massive, but is sectioned off by manufacturer, so it makes..."more

  • 7
    7. Morrison's Auto Inc

    6307 WI-59, Edgerton, WI 53534

    5/5 - 3 reviews 

    used auto parts self service shipping available 

    Need a specific auto part for a DIY project? Visit the convenient self-serve auto parts store for a vast selection of used auto parts. Although short-staffed, they ensure quick and easy ordering and excellent communication. Morrison’s Auto offers superior quality control and excellent service to meet your needs.


          Mushdog71 H. Google Review

    "I purchased a replacement side view mirror for a Ford Explorer. I found the part on-line and called and spoke with David to confirm the connector pin configuration. Within a few hours I had..."more

  • 8
    8. Akright Auto Parts

    106 Bluebird Ln, Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085

    4/5 - 3 reviews 

    used auto parts self service shipping available 

    Find your needed auto parts with ease at this self-serve store offering a wide selection of used car parts. For friendly service and expert advice, visit this store where the knowledgeable staff will help you find the right parts for your vehicle. A cost-effective solution for all your auto part needs.


          Vona R. Google Review

    "I could spend an hour talking about the great service that we received from Akright. I called looking for a car door and rims. The man on the phone was very friendly he took his time making sure..."more

  • 9
    9. Bionic Auto Parts & Sales Milwaukee Inc

    5848 South 13th Street, Milwaukee, WI 53221

    3.7/5 - 3 reviews 

    used auto & truck parts 

    Find all the used auto parts you need at this store, where Hector and the team provide excellent customer service and fair prices. With a wide selection of parts, you can trust that everything will be delivered as promised. See for yourself why many satisfied customers recommend this quality organization.


          Sally R. Google Review

    "We were searching for several body parts for our daughter’s 2007 Buick LaCrosse. Hector was fantastic! Very knowledgeable and polite. We were able to get everything we needed quickly and our..."more

  • 10
    10. Calumet Auto Parts

    8501 W Calumet Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53224

    5/5 - 1 reviews 

    used auto parts shipping available 

    Find a large inventory of used auto parts for late model imports and domestics at this store. With five acres of inventory, they have a great selection of parts from 1992 to present, all fully computerized for easy browsing. Benefit from shop delivery in SE Wisconsin or UPS shipping anywhere, making it easier than ever to find the part you need.


          Peter F. SalvageParts Review

    Great service

    "Extremely satisfied!!! I run a shop and always get top quality used parts from these guys, I have been getting used engines, transmissions and myriad of other parts from them for a few years now..."more

🤓 Did you know... The businesses shown here have been selected and ordered based on both our quality criteria and reviews shared by real people. Learn more about our selection and ranking criteria.

Cities

Counties

FAQs on used auto parts stores in Wisconsin

Are they open on weekends?

+

Some of them, so check their operating hours.

What types of car parts can I find?

+

They typically have a wide range of parts, including engines, transmissions, body panels, interior components, and more.

Can I pay with a credit card?

+

Many salvage yards and used auto parts stores accept credit cards as a payment method. In case of some self-service junkyards, may accept credit cards for entrance fees or additional services, but many primarily deal in cash transactions. The nature of self-service yards, where customers pull their own parts, often involves a simpler and more straightforward payment process, and cash is commonly preferred.

Do they offer warranties?

+

Some provide limited warranties on certain parts. Inquire about their specific policies.

How realiable are the parts they sell?

+

These come from pre-owned automotive components sourced from vehicles that have been retired, damaged, or otherwise no longer in use. Quality and reliability can vary depending on the source and the inspection processes carried out by the salvage yard, junkyard, or seller.

  • Junkyard parts come from vehicles found in a junkyard, a place where decommissioned, wrecked, or older vehicles are stored, and parts are available for salvage. These are cheaper but less carefully inspected or tested compared to other options.
  • Salvage parts are components salvaged from vehicles that have been deemed a total loss by insurance companies due to accidents, damage, or other reasons. These are usually inspected and, if deemed usable, are removed and made available for resale. Salvage yards may have stricter guidelines for assessing the condition of these parts compared to typical junkyards.

While can be a cost-effective solution, especially for older or less common vehicles, it's essential to approach the purchase with caution.

Do they sell used tires and wheels?

+

Yes, you can often find used tires and wheels in good condition.

Can I negotiate prices of used parts?

+

Is possible at some junkyards, particularly if you're purchasing multiple parts.