Best Used Auto Parts Stores in Forestville - Reviews, Perks & Phones
New York

Explore the definitive guide to used auto parts stores in Forestville, NY. We have researched and ranked the Top 10 based on reviews from people who have trusted their services.

  • 1
    Route 20 Auto Parts, Inc.

    Route 20 Auto Parts, Inc.

    10216 Southwestern Blvd, Angola, NY 14006

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    3.8/5 - 4 reviews  open now


          Marshall M. Google Review

    "My initial go-to for certain parts before ordering elsewhere. It's a pull-it-yourself yard as opposed to something like a chain store, but I understand they'll take orders on larger items..."


  • 💵 Want to sell your car in Forestville, NY?

    1. Get an instant offer by calling 1-833-693-5944 or filling out our online form.
    2. Maximize your car's value by selling its parts individually through a classified ad.
    3. Contact junkyards directly from the list below.
    OR Call us Free: 1-833-693-5944
  • 2
    Kloiber Auto Recycling

    Kloiber Auto Recycling

    10353 Darien Rd, Holland, NY 14080

    Used Auto & Truck Parts / Self Service / Shipping Available

    32.3 miles  5/5 - 4 reviews  open now


          Douglas O. Google Review

    "The man I spoke to was knowledgeable and knew exactly what I was talking about when describing the part I was looking for the price quote was better than what I had received from others..."


  • 3
    A Automotive Inc

    A Automotive Inc

    6251 Honeysette Rd, Mayville, NY 14757

    Auto Body Parts Supplier / Used Auto & Classic Car Parts / Self Service

    4.7/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Clint C. Google Review

    "Huge selection of parts for vehicles spanning many years. Can't beat the prices. Friendly employees. Paved parking lot, so you're not pulling in and parking on stones loaded with broken glass..."


  • 4
    Skyway Auto Parts

    Skyway Auto Parts

    637 Tifft St, Buffalo, NY 14220

    Car Repair / Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    31.6 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Jason K. Google Review

    "I had to visit Skyway the other day to pick up a radiator support for my 96 Corsica. This place is just unreal, the people, the atmosphere, the bountiful pile of parts... I found exactly what..."


  • 5
    Gregs Auto Parts

    Gregs Auto Parts

    1980 William St, Buffalo, NY 14206

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service

    34.9 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          David S. Google Review

    "Great place to try to find parts. Ryan helped me this week. They didn't have what I wanted but he looked to get what I needed delivered as fast as he could."


  • 6
    2060 Auto Parts, Inc.

    2060 Auto Parts, Inc.

    2060 William St, Buffalo, NY 14206

    Used Auto Parts

    35 miles  5/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Charles M. Google Review

    "I called on a Friday and was directed to the website found the part I needed ran into website issues used the text service that was on the website and was gotten back to in a timely manner..."


  • 7
    Keystone Automotive - Erie

    Keystone Automotive - Erie

    901 W 12th St Suite 206, Erie, PA 16501

    Used Auto & Truck Parts / Self Service / Shipping Available

    53.2 miles  3.7/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Jules Google Review

    "Very friendly customer service. Terri and Dennis we’re awesome and super helpful. I had to order quite a few parts and swap parts several times for the correct part which was my mistake and..."


  • 8
    Casey's Truck Salvage World, Inc.

    Casey's Truck Salvage World, Inc.

    5651 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043

    Used Auto & Truck Parts

    39.4 miles  4/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Joey K. Google Review

    "Owner is a good honest guy that will do his best to give you a good deal on parts. Buffalo is lucky to have such a good big rig junkyard as this. All the employees were nice and knowledgeable..."


  • 9
    Community Auto Recycling

    Community Auto Recycling

    2540 Manchester Rd, Erie, PA 16506

    Used Auto Parts / Self Service / Shipping Available

    60.6 miles  4/5 - 3 reviews  open now


          Cel C. Google Review

    "Great place, great staff. I spoke to Joe, I needed a full antenna assembly for my Infiniti G20. I ordered the part May 31 and with FedEx Shipping and it arrived quickly today June 2 from PA..."


  • 10
    A-Automotive, Inc.

    A-Automotive, Inc.

    6251 Honeysette Rd, Mayville, NY 14757

    Used Auto Parts Store / Used Auto Parts

    5/5 - 1 reviews  open now


          Jen SalvageParts Review

    Fantastic

    "Last minute we requested a car for a demo for our local volunteer fire dept open house. They accommodated us not only in a very short amount of time but were very easy and helpful on the phone..."


🤓 Did you know... The businesses shown here have been selected and ordered based on both our quality criteria and reviews shared by real people. Learn more about our selection and ranking criteria.

FAQs on used auto parts stores in Forestville

What types of car parts can I find?

+
−

They typically have a wide range of parts, including engines, transmissions, body panels, interior components, and more.

Do they offer warranties?

+
−

Some provide limited warranties on certain parts. Inquire about their specific policies.

Can I pull parts from vehicles myself at a junkyard?

+
−

In many cases, yes, you can pull parts from vehicles yourself at a junkyard. This process is commonly known as "self-service" or "you-pull-it" yards.

Before entering, you typically sign in and may pay an entrance fee or for a container to carry parts. It's crucial to follow safety guidelines, use proper techniques, and be aware of environmental regulations. After removing the parts, you bring them to a payment area, where fees are often based on the type of part.

Are they open on weekends?

+
−

Some of them, so check their operating hours.

Can I pay with a credit card?

+
−

Many salvage yards and used auto parts stores accept credit cards as a payment method. In case of some self-service junkyards, may accept credit cards for entrance fees or additional services, but many primarily deal in cash transactions. The nature of self-service yards, where customers pull their own parts, often involves a simpler and more straightforward payment process, and cash is commonly preferred.

Can I return a part if it doesn't fit or work?

+
−

In case of junkyards, some have strict no-return policies, especially for self-service yards where customers pull their own parts. On the other hand, many salvage yards and used auto parts stores may offer more lenient return policies. However, it's essential to inquire about and understand the specific terms and conditions before making a purchase.

How realiable are the parts they sell?

+
−

These come from pre-owned automotive components sourced from vehicles that have been retired, damaged, or otherwise no longer in use. Quality and reliability can vary depending on the source and the inspection processes carried out by the salvage yard, junkyard, or seller.

  • Junkyard parts come from vehicles found in a junkyard, a place where decommissioned, wrecked, or older vehicles are stored, and parts are available for salvage. These are cheaper but less carefully inspected or tested compared to other options.
  • Salvage parts are components salvaged from vehicles that have been deemed a total loss by insurance companies due to accidents, damage, or other reasons. These are usually inspected and, if deemed usable, are removed and made available for resale. Salvage yards may have stricter guidelines for assessing the condition of these parts compared to typical junkyards.

While can be a cost-effective solution, especially for older or less common vehicles, it's essential to approach the purchase with caution.

Articles that may be of interest